Catholocism and Politics
elenamary
I identify as Catholic. I also identify as politically progressive. These two are not mutually exclusive…in fact one should either have little to do with other or everything to do with it.
I believe in reproductive choice. I believe that every baby born should be a wanted baby. I believe that once a child is born it is our societal and civil obligation to ensure that the child has all basic necessities including food, housing, and education. I believe in federally funded programs like WIC and Head Start. I believe that people have the right to believe that life begins at conception. However, I ask those people to support sex education not based on abstinence. I ask them to support national health care, reformation of the education system, and funding of pre-natal programs. I understand that people fight for an embryonic sac but if they are really fighting for life, we must remember that life is not just the promise of a birth, but the insurance of opportunity to have a fair shake in the world.
I was pleased to see during the election that the Matthew 25 Network (”The Matthew 25 Network is a community of Christians – Catholic, Protestant, Orthodox, Pentecostal, and Evangelical – inspired by the Gospel mandate to put our faith into action to care for our neighbor, especially the most vulnerable.”) came out in support of Obama as the pro-life candidate. And it disturbs me that clergy, believe that they should deny communion to someone because of their politics. I am pro-life, pro-choice and I am catholic
Below is a much more eloquently stated argument on why as humanists and Christians it is important to support Obama as our pro-life President-elect from the site ProLife - ProObama.
Facing an unplanned pregnancy can mean a woman is facing a serious crisis. She needs real help.
Health care for a strong mother and healthy baby. Education - not only well-run preschools but also higher education plans that offer support to mothers - and fathers - who have dreams of supporting themselves and making their own contribution to our economy. Child care programs that respond to the needs of working families.
We could make this happen.
Many pro-life advocacy efforts have focused on the legal status of abortion, rather than addressing prevention of unplanned pregnancy and the needs of pregnant women and families. This has intensified the division and partisanship around this issue, but has little effect at reducing the abortion rate itself.
Making the choice for life possible is a choice we can all make.And it’s a choice Barack Obama has already made, as he challenges us to live up to the call us to “be our brothers’ and sisters’ keepers,” to join together to help women in difficult situations make the choice for life by providing pre- and postnatal care, income support, parent training and caring adoption programs.
We need a systemic, common ground, common sense approach. Nearly two-thirds of women who have abortions are poor. Almost half are college-age or younger. Two thirds are single.
We can drastically reduce abortions by helping reduce unplanned pregnancies and supporting pregnant women and families that need help.
Senator Barack Obama will fight to make sure that every woman in America has the support she needs when facing an unplanned pregnancy. Senator Obama’s grass-roots, faith-based approach of support for women and families will help them when they most need it, preventing abortions by supporting women and families to choose life.





John R.P. Russell Says:
November 14th, 2008 at 10:15 pm
Your beliefs are not Catholic, so why do you identify yourself as Catholic? What kind of Catholicism does not include adherence to Catholic teaching?
elenamary Says:
November 15th, 2008 at 7:30 pm
John, How are my beliefs not Catholic? I think this might help explain my views on my Catholicism http://www.elenamary.com/2007/catholic/
Laura Says:
November 17th, 2008 at 1:55 pm
I don’t understand how a politician who, because he wants to outlaw abortion, is somehow pro-life when that same person has been responsible for the killing of many INNOCENT lives of civilians in war-torn countries and that doesn’t seem to matter. Children are injured and killed everyday because we have an agenda that we deem more important than those civilian lives and that is somehow Pro-Life????? Being against abortion does not bother me, what bothers me are the inconsistencies that exist in the “Pro-Life” political agenda.
abdul-halim Says:
November 19th, 2008 at 12:48 am
Yeah, there is a real discrepancy which never really made sense to me. The Bible contains a wide-range of statements about a whole palette of issues, poverty. war and peace, social justice, theology, etc… so how does the “Christian vote” get reduced to bedroom issues?
Especially in the case of that priest who claimed voting for Obama was a mortal sin… even if you want to talk about the “culture of life” and abortion, shouldn’t that also include war, the death penalty, and health care?
I hope the Matthew 25 isn’t just a short term thing. I would hope the progressive religious types stay more vocal. It is interesting because some of the voices on the conservative side (Schwarzeneggar, Guliani, Ron Paul, even McCain) don’t seem as eager to pander to the “religious right”. I wonder if, as the GOP tries to reorganize, the libertarian fiscal conservatives will end up on top.
John R.P. Russell Says:
November 22nd, 2008 at 10:46 am
Laura,
I, for one, am against both abortion and unjust war - as are the teachings of the Catholic Church - and I do not support politicians like those you describe.
Abdul-Halim,
Voting for Obama precisely because of his stance on abortion (which is not a “bedroom issue”) was a sin. Voting for McCain precisely because of his stance on preemptive war was a sin too. I didn’t vote for either one of them. I don’t think a Catholic can have voted for either one of them in good conscience.
cindylu Says:
November 25th, 2008 at 10:14 pm
The abortion issue is what gets me most morally. I didn’t feel guilty or wrong at all when I voted against Prop 8 (and it’s predecessor Prop 22). However, when it comes to voting on parental notification measures for minors, I feel much more conflicted. In our community, I think the pro-life/pro-choice issues is a little too black and white. I think Mamita Mala at VivirLatino spelled it out quite eloquently. For Latinas, it’s just as much as reproductive choice as it is about sex education, access to contraceptives, access to neonatal care (and good health care in general), access to affordable child care, etc. You get the picture. Like you said, we need to take care of the children after they come out of the womb too.